plaintiff:
- Dr Paul KI Ping-ki
- Hong Kong Washington Company
defendant:
- Next Magazine Publishing Ltd
- CHEUNG Kim-hung
- Toppan Printing Co (HK) Ltd
- YEUNG Wai-hong
- LEE Kwong-fung
jurisdiction_code: HKCA
jurisdiction_name: 香港特別行政區高等法院上訴法庭
case_location:
- 香港特別行政區
case_reason: >-
  1st plaintiff, Dr Paul Ki Ping-ki, appeals against Yuen J's decision made on 2 May 2000 regarding an
case_object:
- leave to appeal out of time from an order made by Registrar Chu on 30 May 1999
judgment_result:
- charge: Appeal against Registrar's order (liability issue)
  result: Dismissed. The Judge had carefully decided the matter and considered all relevant factors regarding
    the exercise of her discretion whether to grant an extension of time for Dr Ki to appeal, and she
    decided correctly on all those four factors.
- charge: Contempt of court (quantum issue)
  result: Dismissed. The letter from the Official Receiver dated 20 January 1999 was not an order but
    rather an opinion held by the Official Receiver, and it did not amount to a contempt of court.
- charge: Registrar's jurisdiction (quantum issue)
  result: Dismissed. The Registrar had the jurisdiction to decide whether the judgment sum could be enforced
    against Next, and her decision was sought by Dr Ki. There was no mistake as alleged by Dr Ki that
    he had made.
judgment_summary: >-
  In this appeal (CACV 175/2000), Dr Paul Ki Ping-ki and Hong Kong Washington Company appealed against
  Yuen J's decision granting leave to Next Magazine Publishing Ltd, CHEUNG Kim-hung, Toppan Printing Co
  (HK) Ltd, YEUNG Wai-hong, and LEE Kwong-fung to set off a debt owed by Dr Ki. The core issues rev
involved_entities:
- entity_name: Hon Leong JA
  reason: Presiding judge in this case, responsible for fact-finding and adjudication.
- entity_name: Woo JA
  reason: Co-presiding judge in this case, responsible for fact-finding and adjudication.
- entity_name: Dr Paul KI Ping-ki
  reason: 1st Plaintiff in the action.
- entity_name: Hong Kong Washington Company
  reason: 2nd Plaintiff in the action.
- entity_name: Next Magazine Publishing Ltd
  reason: 1st Defendant in the action.
- entity_name: CHEUNG Kim-hung
  reason: 2nd Defendant in the action.
- entity_name: Toppan Printing Co (HK) Ltd
  reason: 3rd Defendant in the action.
- entity_name: YEUNG Wai-hong
  reason: 4th Defendant in the action.
- entity_name: LEE Kwong-fung
  reason: 5th Defendant in the action.
- entity_name: Yuen J
  reason: Judge of the Court of First Instance, whose decision is appealed against.
- entity_name: Registrar Chu
  reason: Registrar who made the order on 30 May 1999 regarding set-off of debt.
- entity_name: Official Receiver
  reason: Authority that stated the damages did not form part of Dr Ki's property in bankruptcy.