71 lines
3.6 KiB
YAML
71 lines
3.6 KiB
YAML
plaintiff:
|
|
- LAI SAU KING
|
|
|
|
defendant:
|
|
- LAM CHARP FAT
|
|
|
|
case_reason: Property dispute arising from former cohabitation involving claims for resulting trust over shop and flat, money lent, and damages for breach of loan agreement
|
|
|
|
judgment_summary: |
|
|
This action arose from the former cohabitation between the parties. The plaintiff claimed: (1) 50% beneficial interest in Shop 6, Ground Floor, Jing Ying Building, Yuen Long based on contribution; (2) sole beneficial ownership of Flat A, 1st Floor, Shiu Yat House, On Lok Road, Yuen Long; (3) $50,000 as money lent; and (4) $75,262.07 damages for breach of loan agreement. The court found the defendant's credibility destroyed by photographic evidence proving earlier cohabitation than claimed. Despite concerns about the plaintiff's bankruptcy history and lack of documentation, the court accepted her account. Judgment granted the plaintiff sole beneficial ownership of the flat, proportionate beneficial interest in the shop based on her financial contribution, repayment of $50,000 loan, and $75,262.07 damages. The court also ordered payment of the plaintiff's share of rental income from the shop from September 1987 onwards.
|
|
|
|
jurisdiction_code: HKCFI
|
|
|
|
jurisdiction_name: High Court of the First Instance
|
|
|
|
case_location: Hong Kong
|
|
|
|
case_object:
|
|
- Shop 6, Ground Floor, Jing Ying Building, Yuen Long
|
|
- Flat A, 1st Floor, Shiu Yat House, On Lok Road, Yuen Long
|
|
|
|
judgment_result:
|
|
- claim: Declaration that shop held on resulting trust for plaintiff to extent of 50%
|
|
established: Partially - beneficial interest limited to financial contribution percentage to be ascertained
|
|
- claim: Declaration that plaintiff is sole beneficial owner of flat
|
|
established: Yes
|
|
- claim: $50,000 as money lent
|
|
established: Yes
|
|
- claim: $75,262.07 damages for breach of loan agreement
|
|
established: Yes
|
|
- claim: Share of rental income from shop from August 1987
|
|
established: Yes - from September 1987 onwards
|
|
|
|
involved_entities:
|
|
- entity_name: LAI SAU KING
|
|
reason: Plaintiff claiming beneficial interests in properties and money owed
|
|
- entity_name: LAM CHARP FAT
|
|
reason: Defendant holding legal title to disputed properties
|
|
- entity_name: Kwang Tung Provincial Bank
|
|
reason: Bank that provided $200,000 loan secured by mortgage on the flat
|
|
- entity_name: Yeung Kam Sing
|
|
reason: First tenant of the shop, witness for plaintiff
|
|
- entity_name: Madam Yeung Wan Hen (PW2)
|
|
reason: Witness who testified about plaintiff and defendant's relationship in 1978
|
|
- entity_name: Wong Kwai Hing
|
|
reason: Witness regarding passbook incident in December 1989
|
|
- entity_name: Lam Bo
|
|
reason: Defendant's younger brother, witness for defendant
|
|
- entity_name: Leung Kwok Choi
|
|
reason: Former chef at Sam Sing Restaurant, witness for defendant
|
|
- entity_name: Defendant's mother
|
|
reason: Witness for defendant, claimed to have funded property purchases
|
|
- entity_name: Lam Yuk Wah
|
|
reason: Defendant's sister, witness for defendant
|
|
- entity_name: Lam Chak Tai
|
|
reason: Defendant's elder brother, did not testify despite being in Hong Kong
|
|
- entity_name: Mr. Ottens
|
|
reason: Plaintiff's former husband
|
|
- entity_name: Wai Chi
|
|
reason: Plaintiff's son from previous marriage
|
|
- entity_name: Sam Sing Restaurant
|
|
reason: Defendant's restaurant in Amsterdam where parties met and cohabited
|
|
- entity_name: Hong Kong Restaurant
|
|
reason: Plaintiff's restaurant in Holland
|
|
- entity_name: Mr. Justice Barnett
|
|
reason: Judge presiding over the case
|
|
- entity_name: Mr. J. Poon
|
|
reason: Counsel for plaintiff
|
|
- entity_name: Mr. C.Y. Li
|
|
reason: Counsel for defendant
|