35 lines
2.0 KiB
YAML
35 lines
2.0 KiB
YAML
plaintiff:
|
||
- FONG CHI YUNG trading as LONG FAI BUS CO.
|
||
defendant:
|
||
- CHEUNG HOI YING
|
||
jurisdiction_code: HKDC
|
||
jurisdiction_name: 香港特別行政區區域法院
|
||
case_location:
|
||
- 香港特別行政區
|
||
case_reason: >-
|
||
Plaintiff FONG CHI YUNG trading as LONG FAI BUS CO claims damages from defendant CHEUNG HOI YING for
|
||
case_object:
|
||
- damages in the total sum of $124,570
|
||
judgment_result:
|
||
- charge: P's claim (liability issue)
|
||
result: Dismissed. The court found that the evidence did not sufficiently support P’s allegation of
|
||
illegality in the routes assigned to D, and considered it unlikely that P would benefit public policy
|
||
by invalidating the employment contract on such grounds.
|
||
- charge: D's counterclaim (quantum issue)
|
||
result: Allowed. The court awarded D $23,677.70 with interest from November 4, 2002, until payment.
|
||
Additionally, P is ordered to pay D’s costs of defence and counterclaim including all reserved costs,
|
||
to be taxed if not agreed.
|
||
judgment_summary: >-
|
||
在本案中，原告FONG CHI YUNG（LONG FAI BUS CO）指控被告CHEUNG HOI YING违反雇佣合同并侵占公司财物，要求赔偿124,570港元。法院审理后认为，证据不足以支持原告关于被告非法分配路线的主张，并裁定原告未能证明被告存在违约或侵占行为。相反，法院接受了被告的反诉，判决原告向被告支付23,677.70港元及利息，并承担被告的诉讼费用。
|
||
involved_entities:
|
||
- entity_name: FONG CHI YUNG t/a LONG FAI BUS CO
|
||
reason: Plaintiff in the case.
|
||
- entity_name: CHEUNG HOI YING
|
||
reason: Defendant in the case.
|
||
- entity_name: Deputy District Judge J. Ko in Court
|
||
reason: Presiding judge in this case, responsible for fact-finding and adjudication.
|
||
- entity_name: Ms. Wong (counsel for FONG CHI YUNG t/a LONG FAI BUS CO)
|
||
reason: Counsel representing the plaintiff in the case.
|
||
- entity_name: Mr. Iu (solicitor for CHEUNG HOI YING)
|
||
reason: Solicitor and representative of the defendant in the case.
|